THE 1000 BEST SONGS IN THE WORLD EVER.
299-Judy Collins-Both Sides Now.
1968-It didn’t chart in the UK until 1970, when reaching Number 14.
Best Bit-At 1.36. It’s one of Pop Music’s most thought provoking songs, but the great mystery is how a 22 year old could have acquired the knowledge to write about life’s experiences, so accurately, without having lived through them yet.
‘Both Sides Now’ was written in 1966 by Joni Mitchell, (see also best songs 637 and 558) who was born Roberta Joan Mitchell on November 7th, 1943, in Fort Macleod, Alberta, Canada. The exact date she actually wrote the the song is unknown, but it was definitely before November 17th, 1966, because that was when she first performed it live at ‘The Second Fret,’ Folk club, in Philadelphia, the song and the rest of her performance was finally released in 2014 on ‘All Access Records,’ as the Album ‘Joni Mitchel: Live at the Second Fret 1966.’ Mitchell has said that ‘Both Sides Now’ was inspired by a passage in ‘Henderson the Rain King,’ which is a 1959 novel by Saul Bellow (1915-2005.) Mitchell has said, ‘I was reading ‘Henderson the Rain King’ on a plane, and early on in the book Henderson is also up in a plane. He’s on his way to Africa and he looks down and sees these clouds too, and I immediately started writing the song. I had no idea that the song would become as popular as it did.’
‘Both Sides Now’ was first released by the American Folk singer Dave Van Ronk (1936-2002) and the Hudson Dusters under the title ‘Clouds’ in June 1967. The songs author Joni Mitchell included the song on her second studio Album ‘Clouds,’ from May 1969. The most commercially successful version of the song is this recording from Judy Collins, who recorded it for her sixth studio Album ‘Wildflowers,’ from October 1967. It was released with the title ‘Both Sides Now,’ and was the only single issued from the Album. The song was produced by Mark Abramson, (1934-2007) and arranged by Joshua Rifkin.
Judy Collins was born Judith Marjorie Collins on May 1st, 1939, in Seattle, Washington, United States, this song, along with her renditions of ‘Amazing Grace’, (1970) and ‘Send in the Clowns’ (1975) are considered her signature songs. As a teenager Judy Collins studied Classical piano under the tutelage of Antonia Brico, (1902-1989) Brico took a dim view when Collins developed an interest in Folk music. Years later after she became internationally known, she invited Brico to one of her concerts in Denver. When they met after the performance, Brico took both of Collin’s hands into his, looked wistfully at her fingers and said, ‘Little Judy- you really could have gone places.’ In the 1960’s Judy Collins would perform many songs by aspiring Folk music writers such as Eric Anderson, Fred Neil, (1936-2001) (see also best songs 388) and Joni Mitchel, well before they became famous. It was Collins who introduced a then unknown Mitchell to the crowd at the 1966 ‘Newport Folk Festival’. Judy Collins version of ‘Both Sides Now’ reached Number 8 in America on Billboard, Number 6 in Canada, and Number 7 in New Zealand, in 1968, and Number 14 in the UK in 1970.
The discography of Judy Collins includes 36 studio Albums released between 1961-2022, and 21 singles released between 1963-2014, there are at least 24 official compilation Albums and nine live Albums available. In America ‘Wildflowers’ is her most commercially successful Album reaching Number 5 on the Billboard 200 Album chart, while four of her singles have made the Billboard Hot 100, with ‘Both Sides Now’ peaking the highest at Number 8. In the UK, Judy Collins’ most successful Album is her 10th studio Album ‘Judith’ from 1975, which peaked at Number 7, while three of her singles have reached the UK top 40, with ‘Amazing Grace’ from 1970, charting the highest at Number 5.
Joni Mitchell re-recorded ‘Both Sides Now’ in 2000 in an Orchestral fashion, for her 17th studio Album ‘Both Sides Now.’ She has also performed the song on numerous occasions, notably on July 24th, 2022, when at age of 78 she performed it with the American singer Brandi Carlile. With her voice shaken by age and the after-effects of a 2015 brain aneurysm, it is said that Joni Mitchell turned back the clock and delivered a powerfully emotional performance imbued with the wisdom of her life experience, punctuated with the last line of the song, ‘I really don’t know life at all.’ ‘Both Sides Now’ has been covered on numerous occasions down the years by dozens of different artists, including notable versions by Frank Sinatra, (1968) Clannad, as a duet with Paul Young, (1991) and Herbie Hancock (2007.)
‘Both Sides Now’ is about how your views, and the views and expectations of people you know change as you experience events that happen in your life. The wonderful future you imagined as a youngster may not have turned out as you expected. What seemed a simple path to follow at 16, proved to be fraught with dangers at 66.
‘Bows and flows of angel hair, and ice cream castles in the air, and feathered canyons everywhere, I’ve looked at clouds that way.’